Monday, December 2, 2013

Killing Characters

         This is just my own opinion that I feel needed to be addressed, but why do the writers of shows have to kill off main characters? You know the feeling regardless of what type of media you are into. Let me set the stage. You’re invested in a show, movie, or book for that matter. You've somehow become attached to a main character. He has resolve, he’s good looking, and he’s a man’s hero. Or perhaps she's outgoing, beautiful, calm and adjusted. You've officially decided that you want to model the rest of your life around this character, until you're done with that book/movie/show, of course. Just when you decide, “it’s okay to assume this character will make it to the end of this show/movie/book,” he gets about a million arrows shot through him before he utters his last breath.
          This is NOT okay. Specifically in any show, because this blogs about television. More specifically, in shows that kill off main characters like it’s nobody’s business. I’m talking about you, “The Walking Dead” and “The Game of Thrones.” I get the fact that writers want to make their story line dramatic, but does that mean they have to literally kill off the whole plot line they've just spent the past sixty minutes of my life developing.
Isn't that extremely counter-productive, though? I don’t spend hours painting a picture in which a newly-wed couple discovers their pregnancy, excited for their new life together, then set the canvas on fire! You've pretty much just destroyed everything you've been working so hard on. Why would you excite me with the idea of the couple visiting their child’s oblivious grandmother, to excite her with the news, and then as the care-free couple happily trudge along their quest, have the wife stabbed in the womb? I’ll repeat that, STABBED IN THE WOMB. That's just brutal. This turned out to be a lot more specific than it needed to be, but the point remains.
The worst part of all of this is that I keep coming back to the shows. It’s like that terrible relationship you have. You know, the one that no matter how many times you break up, it just doesn't seem to actually end. You've been with this person for so long, you were happy with them at one point, and you hold onto those memories. However, something changed along the line (maybe he became a psychopath who kills off everyone you care about) and you got into a big argument. But he’s kept calling you back to him. He seems changed with each new call. He acts like he used to be when you first started up your relationship, like he’s learned his lesson. There’s something about his voice that says “I won’t kill everyone you care about, I promise.”  So you take him back. THEN HE GOES AND KILLS EVERY NEW PERSON YOU STARTED CARING ABOUT. I guess there’s something about killing off these characters that draws the viewers in.

 If you’re going to kill a main character, at least let it be a villain. If you just HAVE to kill off a good guy, at least let it be at the end of the show, so we have sentimental feelings for that character that stay with us.“Breaking Bad” got it right; they only killed off villains while the show was running. That was a pretty successful show, too. I swear if Daryl Dixon, Jon Snow, or Jaime Lannister gets killed off, I’m done with television.

6 comments:

  1. I completely agree with your argument in this post. It's very strongly written, and you do a wonderful job getting your point across. By reflecting your angry emotions you display your passion towards these shows, which makes these posts more agreeable and interesting for your audience. I loved how you compared killing off characters to a bad relationship in such a great way. Your writing is very strong and analytical in many ways. Your ability to raise questions to your audience, in this one, why are characters killed off, is what makes this blog really strong. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your posts have become better in the sense that they don't rely heavily on summary. The fact that you've broadened the scope of your posts to topics beyond the shows themselves makes for strong and engaging writing. I like your analysis, but I also like the fact that you are able to keep your readers interested; with this post in particular, I found that third paragraph where you compared killing off characters to setting a canvas on fire to be a good example of the latter. You've definitely found your focus for this blog. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really like this post because I do agree with your argument. The way you wrote this showed passion, which made me want to read it more. I can feel your pain through this post because I also get frustrated when they kill one of my favorite characters in a show. But just like how you compared shows to being a bad relationship, I still continue to watch the show. This is my favorite blog from the rest of your entries, I noticed how you started your blog from tv summaries to topics such as these. Your blog out of everyones I read, made the most improvement. Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  4. We discussed this in class, but often, the reason a character is killed off is because an actor has decided to leave the show and take other work. An unfortunate reality. As for Game of Thrones, the show follows the book pretty closely. I didn't think I would get past Sean Bean's fateful exit, but somehow I pulled through, until I lost Kaal Drogo, and then, of course, "The Red Wedding." But now I'm so invested that I must continue watching -- too much is at stake!

    I'd imagine you feel the same way. Great topic, however! It's definitely pertinent to most people!

    ReplyDelete
  5. This blog post was heavily discussed in class and the reason why the kill characters is because the actor/actress decided to leave the show. It's dumb, right? They should kill characters based on the story and not because of the convenience of people. You proposed a great topic. I hate it when my favorite characters die, like in the movie The Hunger Games, Cinna dies. I love him. Grrrr. I feel your frustration and pain.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I like the topic of this post because it happens in every single one of my favorite shows. I've been trying to think of one where it hasn't, but I can't. I guess it adds more drama to the show, but sometimes I feel like not watching some of them anymore because they kill off too many of my favorite characters! I really liked how you wrote about this topic especially with a touch of humor. Good Work!

    ReplyDelete